Worst Signings of the 2023/24 Premier League Season: A Recap of Underperforming Players

As the 2023/24 Premier League season concludes, it’s time to reflect on the numerous transfers that took place last summer. While some players exceeded expectations, others failed to make a significant impact, earning them a spot on the list of the worst signings of the season.

1. Sandro Tonali (Newcastle United)

Arriving at St. James’ Park with a hefty £60 million price tag, the Italian midfielder was expected to bolster Newcastle’s European campaign. However, Tonali’s season was marred by a ten-month ban for breaking Italian gambling regulations during his time with AC Milan. His absence proved costly for Newcastle, who struggled with injuries throughout the season.

2. Mason Mount (Manchester United)

Mount’s £60 million move from Chelsea to Manchester United generated considerable buzz during the 2023 summer transfer window. Unfortunately, recurring injuries prevented the England international from showcasing his abilities consistently. Manchester United will hope for a more significant contribution from Mount next season.

3. Ansu Fati (Brighton & Hove Albion)

Touted as Lionel Messi’s successor, the young Spanish forward joined Brighton on loan in January. Fati made an instant impact, scoring two goals in his first five games. However, injuries soon derailed his progress, leaving fans wondering what could have been.

4. Kalvin Phillips (West Ham United)

Phillips’ £42 million transfer to Manchester City initially excited fans, but he soon found himself warming the bench. A subsequent loan move to West Ham United aimed to revive his career, but high-profile errors against Bournemouth and Manchester United ultimately lost him the trust of manager David Moyes.

5. Matheus Nunes (Manchester City)

Pep Guardiola’s praise for Matheus Nunes, following his £53 million acquisition, raised expectations. However, the Portuguese midfielder struggled to break into the starting lineup and was largely limited to cameo appearances throughout the season.

These five signings serve as a reminder that even the most promising talents can fail to meet expectations in the unpredictable world of football. With the 2023/24 Premier League season concluded, clubs will undoubtedly aim to learn from these disappointing transfers as they prepare for another summer transfer window.